RETHINKING MORTGAGE FINANCING: STRIKING THE BALANCE BETWEEN REPAYMENT OBLIGATION AND PROFITS

&NewLine;<p><strong>INTRODUCTION<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Undoubtedly&comma; the evidence of our living conditions&nbsp&semi;points&nbsp&semi;to one conclusion &&num;8211&semi; we are in difficult times and serious economic crisis&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Sadly&comma; there is little hope in the initiatives that can help curb&comma; reduce or mitigate against the rising cost of living driven&nbsp&semi;predominantly&nbsp&semi;by&nbsp&semi;escalating&nbsp&semi;fuel prices and the fast depreciation of the Ghana cedi against major trading currencies&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>At an increasing inflation rate&comma; the purchasing value of money from disposable&nbsp&semi;income is eroding at an alarming rate&period; Incomes from investments and businesses are equally not spared &&num;8211&semi; and&nbsp&semi;with no prospect of a&nbsp&semi;short to&nbsp&semi;mid-term&nbsp&semi;economic recovery&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>In these unsettled times&comma; persons with mortgage repayment obligations denominated in United States Dollars &lpar;&dollar;&rpar; deserve our fervent prayers&period;&nbsp&semi;Today&comma;&nbsp&semi;a&nbsp&semi;&dollar;500 monthly&nbsp&semi;mortgage&nbsp&semi;repayment commitment&nbsp&semi;will&nbsp&semi;have jumped from GHS2&comma;881&period;55 in December 2020 to GHS3&comma;519&period;25 using&nbsp&semi;exchange&nbsp&semi;rates quoted on the Bank of Ghana website&nbsp&semi;– definitely&nbsp&semi;higher at a commercial bank conversion&period;&nbsp&semi;The indicative&nbsp&semi;minimum increase of&nbsp&semi;22&period;1&percnt;&nbsp&semi;in monthly repayments&nbsp&semi;over the relatively short period&nbsp&semi;is a worrying trend&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>With this&nbsp&semi;leap&comma; many will not be able to honour their monthly repayment commitments&period; The resultant outcome of defaults &lpar;estimated&nbsp&semi;to be&nbsp&semi;high&rpar;&nbsp&semi;provides&nbsp&semi;an opportunity for the rethinkingof mortgage financing in Ghana&nbsp&semi;especially when&nbsp&semi;a short-term&nbsp&semi;economic recovery&nbsp&semi;may not be attained&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>In this article&comma; we hope the interventions discussed will provide the signposts for policymakers&sol;regulators&comma; financial institutions&comma; and borrowers in designing new approaches to mortgage financing to save the subsector from collapse&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p><strong>HOUSING&nbsp&semi;<&sol;strong><strong>AND MORTGAGES<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Ghana’s housing deficit is observed to have reduced by 33&percnt; since the year 2000 following the 2021 Population and Housing Census&semi;&nbsp&semi;a feat&nbsp&semi;the country&nbsp&semi;could&nbsp&semi;not have achieved without the significant contribution of mortgage financing&period;&nbsp&semi;Although remarkably progressive&comma;&nbsp&semi;the current estimated housing deficit of 1&period;8 million remains high&comma;&nbsp&semi;requiring&nbsp&semi;a&nbsp&semi;coordinated&nbsp&semi;strategy&nbsp&semi;for&nbsp&semi;the supply and demand&nbsp&semi;management&nbsp&semi;of housing provision&nbsp&semi;going forward&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Government and private sector interests in providing more housing units&nbsp&semi;remain high&period;&nbsp&semi;However&comma;&nbsp&semi;financing options for the purchase&nbsp&semi;and ownership&nbsp&semi;of these houses remain limited&period;&nbsp&semi;Individuals are unable to&nbsp&semi;raise the required financing from personal sources&nbsp&semi;as the same is beyond the means of&nbsp&semi;the majority of the populace&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Therefore&comma; mortgage&nbsp&semi;financing has become the most preferred financing option for many homeowners either seeking to acquire new homes&comma; complete or renovate existing ones or undertake equity release for other commercial or personal purposes&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>A mortgage&comma;&nbsp&semi;serving as a lien or claim held by a lender on the title to a property of a borrower in exchange for a loan&nbsp&semi;mostly to acquire properties&comma;&nbsp&semi;is a creature of statute&period;&nbsp&semi;By law&comma; an executed mortgage only operates as an encumbrance or a charge on aproperty&nbsp&semi;serving as&nbsp&semi;security for the repayment obligation&nbsp&semi;under the mortgage agreement&period;&nbsp&semi;In effect&comma; a mortgage does not result in a change of ownership of the property&comma; the subject matter of the mortgage agreement&period;&nbsp&semi;The borrower retains the right to redeem the property both in law and equity – once a mortgage&comma; always a mortgage&comma; except in&nbsp&semi;circumstances of defaults where the lender takes steps to repossess the mortgaged property&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Although the financing regime for loans for construction or purchase of homes or properties is also regulated&comma;&nbsp&semi;issues of pricing&comma; tenure&comma; etc&period; are matters of individual negotiations with the financing institution&period;&nbsp&semi;By practice&comma;&nbsp&semi;the average tenure for a mortgage is 15 years and&nbsp&semi;largely denominated in United States Dollars &lpar;&dollar;&rpar;&nbsp&semi;on the requisite approval from the Bank of Ghana&nbsp&semi;to transact in&nbsp&semi;same&period;&nbsp&semi;Equally&comma;&nbsp&semi;mortgage rates could be fixed or&nbsp&semi;adjustable subject to agreed conditions&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p><strong>THE BORROWER’S&nbsp&semi;<&sol;strong><strong>PRIMARY&nbsp&semi;<&sol;strong><strong>OBLIGATION<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>The borrower&&num;8217&semi;s primary obligation is to honour without fail&comma; the agreed repayment amount in full and on time&period;&nbsp&semi;This obligation is fundamental to the enjoyment of rights associated with the mortgaged property as failure puts the same at risk&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Underlying this obligation are&nbsp&semi;matters&nbsp&semi;of interest rates&comma; tenure&comma; and&nbsp&semi;the&nbsp&semi;currency&nbsp&semi;denomination of the repayment amount&nbsp&semi;flowing from the denomination of the principal facility amount&period;&nbsp&semi;A&nbsp&semi;mortgage&nbsp&semi;facility denominated in US dollars &lpar;&dollar;&rpar;&nbsp&semi;mostly attracts&nbsp&semi;an average of 13&percnt; interest rate&nbsp&semi;over an average tenure of 15 years&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>It is erroneous to assume that&comma;&nbsp&semi;a lower interest rate compared torates of&nbsp&semi;commercial loans denominated in Ghana Cedis over a longer tenure implies&nbsp&semi;a flexible repayment obligation&nbsp&semi;– on conversion&comma;&nbsp&semi;such&nbsp&semi;interest rates&nbsp&semi;impose&nbsp&semi;a&nbsp&semi;higher repayment obligation&nbsp&semi;than Ghana cedi denominated&nbsp&semi;loans&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Honouring scheduled repayment amounts has become the major reason for defaults in repayment obligations&period;&nbsp&semi;A&nbsp&semi;mortgage&nbsp&semi;facility&nbsp&semi;denominated in US dollars is&nbsp&semi;to&nbsp&semi;be repaid in US dollars&period;&nbsp&semi;The difficulties arise when a&nbsp&semi;Ghana Cedi earner&nbsp&semi;&lpar;borrower&rpar;undertakes to repay a mortgaged facility in US dollars&period;&nbsp&semi;In effect&comma; the borrower must&nbsp&semi;raise the&nbsp&semi;Ghana Cedis equivalent&nbsp&semi;each month using the US dollar selling rate of the financial institution as the conversion rate&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>The culminating effect of a&nbsp&semi;rapidly&nbsp&semi;depreciating&nbsp&semi;currency &lpar;Ghana Cedis&rpar;&nbsp&semi;is that&comma;&nbsp&semi;a&nbsp&semi;borrower’s&nbsp&semi;scheduled&nbsp&semi;repayment obligation&nbsp&semi;increases&nbsp&semi;daily and&nbsp&semi;at a fast rate&period;&nbsp&semi;Today&comma;&nbsp&semi;a borrower is unable to forecast and plan for his or her repayments as&nbsp&semi;the US dollar&nbsp&semi;exchange rate&nbsp&semi;has&nbsp&semi;become unpredictable&period;&nbsp&semi;A borrower only prepares to pay more on monthly basis&nbsp&semi;whilst contending with the increasing&nbsp&semi;economic&nbsp&semi;pressures&nbsp&semi;on his or her disposableincome&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>At&nbsp&semi;this rate&comma;&nbsp&semi;the borrower’s ability to make repayments on schedule will become strained&nbsp&semi;resulting in defaults&comma;&nbsp&semi;andincreasing the stock of non-performing loans&nbsp&semi;for financial institutions&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p><strong>INTERVENTIONS IN TIMES OF CRISIS<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>With exchange rate stability or predictability&comma;&nbsp&semi;a&nbsp&semi;mortgage repayment obligation&nbsp&semi;denominated in US dollars &lpar;&dollar;&rpar; could&nbsp&semi;with some level of certainty be honoured&period;&nbsp&semi;In the absence of the same coupled with the&nbsp&semi;economic crisis&nbsp&semi;as we&nbsp&semi;are&nbsp&semi;currently experiencing&comma; borrowers&nbsp&semi;will require some interventions&nbsp&semi;to navigate the difficult times and resume&nbsp&semi;scheduled&nbsp&semi;repayments once&nbsp&semi;economic conditions improve&period;&nbsp&semi;These&nbsp&semi;interventions&nbsp&semi;could&nbsp&semi;also form the basis for&nbsp&semi;an overhaul of&nbsp&semi;our mortgage financing regime&period;&nbsp&semi;The proposed intervention include&colon;A&period;&nbsp&semi;<strong>Mortgage<&sol;strong><strong>&nbsp&semi;loan denomination mandate by the Bank of Ghana<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Financial institutions may view this call as unattractive for mortgage financing but&nbsp&semi;it has the potential to provide long-term&nbsp&semi;forex&nbsp&semi;stability and improve the repayment obligation of borrowers&period;&nbsp&semi;Therefore&comma; the&nbsp&semi;central bank must&nbsp&semi;take steps to&nbsp&semi;revoke all approvals or consents for the&nbsp&semi;US dollar denomination of mortgages in Ghana&period;&nbsp&semi;Guidelines must&nbsp&semi;be&nbsp&semi;developed&nbsp&semi;to aid&nbsp&semi;a fair and equitable&nbsp&semi;conversion of existing US dollar denomination mortgages into Ghana Cedis following the revocation of approvals or consents&period;&nbsp&semi;Further&comma; the Bank of Ghana must mandate only Ghana Cedis denominated&nbsp&semi;mortgage loans in Ghana&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>These pricing&nbsp&semi;initiatives&nbsp&semi;have become&nbsp&semi;necessary options at&nbsp&semi;minimizing the&nbsp&semi;immediate effects of&nbsp&semi;the depreciation of the Ghana Cedis and resetting the&nbsp&semi;pricing regime for mortgage financing in Ghana&period;&nbsp&semi;B&period;&nbsp&semi;<strong>Adoption of &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;<&sol;strong><strong>Conversion rate plus Margin<&sol;strong><strong>”&nbsp&semi;<&sol;strong><strong>financing model<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Absence&nbsp&semi;the political will&nbsp&semi;of the Bank of Ghana&nbsp&semi;to&nbsp&semi;implement the first intervention&comma;&nbsp&semi;financial institutions must&nbsp&semi;incorporate&nbsp&semi;a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;<strong><em>conversion rate plus margin<&sol;em><&sol;strong>”&nbsp&semi;repayment&nbsp&semi;formula into their mortgage financing denominated in US dollars&period;&nbsp&semi;This formula may reduce the overall financial gains from a mortgage facility over its&nbsp&semi;tenure but&nbsp&semi;could improve the&nbsp&semi;loan servicing rates than the current state of affairs&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>By this formula&comma;&nbsp&semi;a loan tenure will be divided into&nbsp&semi;phases and assigned a&nbsp&semi;pre-agreed&nbsp&semi;applicable&nbsp&semi;exchange rate &lpar;as maximum ceiling&rpar; plus a margin&nbsp&semi;as the conversion rate for repayment obligation denominated in US dollars&nbsp&semi;during the phase&period;&nbsp&semi;The conversion rate for the next phase is adjusted using the same formula for the previous phase&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>With the right financial modeling&comma;&nbsp&semi;certainty and predictability will be restored in the conversation rate&nbsp&semi;for mortgage loans over a specified phase of the tenure&period;&nbsp&semi;This will aid borrowers in planning&nbsp&semi;for their repayment obligation&nbsp&semi;than&nbsp&semi;it pertains to in&nbsp&semi;the current&nbsp&semi;circumstance of&nbsp&semi;volatile exchange rate increases&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Financial institutions could pilot and fine-tune&nbsp&semi;this model based&nbsp&semi;on&nbsp&semi;insights before mass rollouts&period;C&period;&nbsp&semi;<strong>Use of conventional approaches<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Mortgage loan defaults are not a new&nbsp&semi;phenomenon&nbsp&semi;– as no approach has entirely prevented the same&period;&nbsp&semi;As containment strategy&comma;&nbsp&semi;restructuring negotiations and&nbsp&semi;repossession processes have been used over the years to ensure resumption of repayment obligations or&nbsp&semi;forfeiture of&nbsp&semi;security for loans respectively&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>It is prudent to continue&nbsp&semi;and enhance&nbsp&semi;these conventional approaches with&nbsp&semi;a deep appreciation of&nbsp&semi;the general economic circumstances and with a touch of humanity&nbsp&semi;– although least expected when financial recoveries&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Financial institutions must set early warning thresholds&nbsp&semi;and strictly&nbsp&semi;take early remedies steps to engage borrowers&nbsp&semi;to avoid compounding&nbsp&semi;repayment obligations over months&period;&nbsp&semi;In&nbsp&semi;worse casescenarios&comma;&nbsp&semi;repossession&nbsp&semi;efforts&nbsp&semi;either through independent&nbsp&semi;attempts&nbsp&semi;or the courts must be&nbsp&semi;pursued&nbsp&semi;with&nbsp&semi;an open mind and&nbsp&semi;opportunity for the borrower to&nbsp&semi;redeem his obligations under an executed mortgage agreement&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p><strong>CONCLUSION<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p>Difficult times do not warrant a waiver of obligations&comma; especially financial ones&period;&nbsp&semi;Therefore&comma; we do not anticipate borrowers under mortgage agreements are expecting financial institutions to write off their repayment obligations&period;&nbsp&semi;However&comma;&nbsp&semi;the need to provide more flexible and responsive repayment opportunities can&nbsp&semi;also&nbsp&semi;not be ignored&nbsp&semi;in the current economic crisis we find ourselves in&period;&nbsp&semi;It is to this end that&comma;&nbsp&semi;we are advocating for&nbsp&semi;the interventions to provide immediate and long-term cushion for&nbsp&semi;borrowers while improving the&nbsp&semi;general&nbsp&semi;loan servicing rates for the mortgage financing&nbsp&semi;subsector&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p><strong>About the Authors<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p><strong>RICHARD NUNEKPEKU<&sol;strong>&nbsp&semi;is the Managing Partner of&nbsp&semi;<strong>SUSTINERI ATTORNEYS PRUC<&sol;strong>&comma;&nbsp&semi;a client-centric boutique law firm specialized in transactions&comma; corporate legal services&comma; dispute resolutions&comma; and tax&period;&nbsp&semi;Richard&nbsp&semi;leads the firm&&num;8217&semi;s Corporate and Commercial Practice with a focus on&nbsp&semi;FinTech&nbsp&semi;and&nbsp&semi;Start-upsdevelopment&period;&nbsp&semi;He is reachable at&nbsp&semi;<a href&equals;"mailto&colon;richard&commat;sustineriattorneys&period;com">richard&commat;sustineriattorneys&period;com<&sol;a><&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p><strong>CECILIA ANTWI KYEM<&sol;strong>&nbsp&semi;is a Part II student of the Ghana School of Law and interns at&nbsp&semi;<strong>SUSTINERI ATTORNEYS PRUC&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;strong>Cecilia has an interest in Commercial Transactions&comma; Financial Technology &lpar;Fintech&rpar;&comma; Start-ups and SMEs&comma; Company Law and Contracts as well as Alternative Dispute Resolution&period; She is reachable at&nbsp&semi;<a href&equals;"mailto&colon;kyemcecilia&commat;gmail&period;com">kyemcecilia&commat;gmail&period;com<&sol;a><&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version